In traditional redraft fantasy football, bye weeks are a fundamental part of weekly roster management. Players with the same bye? Big problem. Draft too many Week 9 byes? Time to reshuffle. But in Best Ball, where there are no waivers, no trades, and no start-sit decisions, the impact of bye weeks is often misunderstood and typically overrated.
Let’s break down why that is.
New to Best Ball? Check out Jay’s Beginners Guide!
Bye Weeks in Best Ball Fantasy Football
In Best Ball, you draft a team of 18 or 20 players (depending on format), and that’s it. No setting lineups, no subbing in for injured players, no worrying about bad matchups. Just draft, and let the season play out.
So, when someone says, “You shouldn’t draft two QBs with the same bye week,” the question is: Why not?
Myth: Bye Weeks Cause You to “Lose” a Week
Here’s the logic most people use: If your two quarterbacks have the same bye, you’ll “score a zero” at that position that week. Sounds catastrophic, right?
But let’s zoom out.
In Best Ball, your final score is the cumulative total of all 17 weeks (in most formats), not a weekly win-loss record. So while you might have a low QB score in Week 7, if that pair of quarterbacks is consistently giving you strong points in the other 16 weeks, you’ve come out ahead.
The same applies to tight ends, kickers (in formats that use them), and even wide receivers and running backs. A zero in a given week isn’t ideal, but it’s not inherently worse than having multiple players put up 4-6 points instead. The net outcome matters more than a single blank spot.
Bye Week Overlap Can Be a Feature, Not a Bug
Consider this: If all your QBs or TEs are off in Week 9, that means they’re all playing the other 16 weeks. That’s 16 chances for them to contribute to your lineup. If you spread out bye weeks to “cover” each other, you may be lowering your ceiling by drafting worse players just to avoid a one-week hole.
Best Ball is about upside, not floor. The goal isn’t to survive each week, it’s to build a high-scoring juggernaut over 17 weeks. Sacrificing a few points in one week in exchange for higher scoring potential across the rest of the season is a winning strategy.
When Bye Weeks Might Matter
There are a few situations where bye weeks deserve some attention:
- Underdog’s Best Ball Mania & Playoff Formats
In Best Ball Mania (BBM) or similar large-field tournaments, the final weeks (15-17) are a playoff structure. You want your team at full strength during those weeks, so a concentration of late bye weeks (e.g., Weeks 13 and 14) could impact your team’s readiness for playoff qualification. - On the Margins
If you’re drafting only two QBs or two TEs, and they share a bye, you’re guaranteeing a zero at that position for one week. That’s not the end of the world, but you may consider adding a third to give yourself coverage. That said, elite QBs and TEs often score so well that you can still advance with a bye week hole if you nail the rest of your build.
What Matters More Than Bye Weeks?
- Roster construction: Are you building with positional balance and upside in mind? (article here!)
- Stacking: Are you creating correlated lineups (QB-WR, WR-TE, etc.) to maximize spike weeks? (article here!)
- Player archetypes: Are you balancing consistent scorers with high variance spike week players?
- Draft capital allocation: Are you investing properly at each position to reflect Best Ball scoring formats?
These all move the needle far more than agonizing over a couple of players sharing a bye week.
Bye Weeks Are Overrated in Best Ball
Are bye weeks completely irrelevant in Best Ball? Not quite. But their impact is dwarfed by more important strategic elements like roster construction, upside chasing, and player correlation.
So the next time someone tells you not to draft two QBs or three WRs with the same bye week, remember: This isn’t redraft. You’re building a rocket ship, not a bus. One lost week doesn’t derail the mission.
Let the others avoid players based on byes. You’ll be the one benefiting when those same players are scoring 25+ points in Week 15 and pushing your Best Ball team into the finals.
Before you go, check out Club Fantasy’s 2025 Best Ball Fantasy Football Rankings! We also have a few more Best Ball Strategy articles you can check out!
Be sure you’re following Jay on X/Twitter! You can also find more great fantasy football content here!